The scorecard

Every format on this site is graded the same way. We wrote down 33 things a good SEC season ought to do, from playing every rivalry on its usual weekend to settling the championship on the field, and then we simulated 5,000 seasons of each format and checked every one of them. A plus means the format does it, a tilde means it does it most of the time, and an × means it doesn't. Footballness is the share of those things a format gets right, with a tilde counting as half. The bold rows group related items and are graded the same way. Where our own judgment, written down before we ran a single season, disagreed with the numbers, the number wins and our call is shown in brackets. How the grades are made. Further down the page: what a season of each format would bring in.

+ does it · ~ most of the time · × does not · · does not apply · ? not measured yet

One row, Every Game Counts, comes from a smaller sample because it is expensive to measure. For 32 of the seasons we took 12 games each and replayed each one 40 times as a win and 40 times as a loss, with every other result left alone, to see whether that game changed either team's shot at the title by 5 points or more, or changed who it played next or where.

codepatternseven-finalchaseseven-settleeight-finalseven-semisfour-cupspools-playoffpool-playmini-playoffstatus-quotwo-cupstwo-cups-b
FOOTFootballness: the share of patterns kept0.88 ★0.860.830.810.790.780.780.770.760.750.730.68
RIVLRivalries Are Kept1.001.000.750.750.750.750.751.000.751.000.500.50
  RRPReserved Rivalry Pair++~~~~~+~+~~
  TGAThanksgiving Anchor++~~~+~+~+~~
  RIORivalry in the Opener+++++~++++~~
  NSCNeutral-Site Classic++++++++++~~
SEASThe Season Is the Playoff0.750.750.750.500.751.000.750.501.000.251.001.00
  EGCEvery Game Counts+++++++×+~++
  ERLEarly Results Shape Late Opponents~~~×~+~++×++
SORTLike Plays Like0.831.000.830.670.830.750.880.670.881.000.880.88
  LPLLike Plays Like+++~+++++·++
  WPLWinners' Path, Losers' Path+++++++++·++
  FOPFresh Opponent Preferred~+~~~~~×~+~~
  CBCCross-Bracket Consolation·····~····++
  ORPOrthogonal Partitions·+····+·+···
HOPESomething to Play For0.671.000.670.500.671.000.830.831.000.500.830.83
  PHSA Gumbo Game Has Stakes~+~×~+~++~++
  SCHSecond Chance++++++++++++
  TROA Trophy to Lift~+~~~++~+×~~
FELDSettled on the Field1.000.700.901.000.900.800.900.800.750.600.700.50
  DEFDecisive Final+×+++++×+×~×
  CFHOnly Head-to-Head Carries+++++·++·+··
  NPCNo Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flip+~+++++++~++
  CSFSuper Final When Earned·····+····+~
  WHMWhom, Not How Much+++++++++~++
  STKSomething Stinks++~+~×~+×+××
CREDThe Champion Is Credible0.751.001.000.751.001.000.750.500.751.001.000.75
  SSUStrength Survives Upsets~++~++~~~++~
  SMPSufficient Sample+++++++~++++
KNOWFans Know Where and When0.830.900.750.920.670.500.581.000.421.000.670.67
  PSSPublished Saturdays~+~~~+~+~+++
  KOPKnown Opponents+++++×++~+××
  HABHome/Away Balance++++~~~+×+++
  FVAFixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent++~+~××+×·~~
  HAPHome/Away Pigeonhole············
  NTCNotice~~~+~~~+~·~~
  DFVDynamic Field, Fair Venue+·+++++·+·++
FITSFits Inside the Season1.001.001.001.001.001.001.000.751.001.000.500.50
  NINNine and Done++++++++++++
  BYRBye Rhythm+++++++~++××
PAYSThe Format Pays Its Way1.000.251.001.000.750.750.750.250.750.500.750.75
  TTETitle Event+×+++++×+×++
  BIDProtect the Bids+~++~~~~~+~~

Totals

seven-final

0.88of 1.00

22 honored · 7 strained · 0 broken · 4 not rated

chase

0.86of 1.00

23 honored · 4 strained · 2 broken · 4 not rated

seven-settle

0.83of 1.00

19 honored · 10 strained · 0 broken · 4 not rated

eight-final

0.81of 1.00

20 honored · 7 strained · 2 broken · 4 not rated

seven-semis

0.79of 1.00

17 honored · 12 strained · 0 broken · 4 not rated

four-cups

0.78of 1.00

20 honored · 7 strained · 3 broken · 3 not rated

pools-playoff

0.78of 1.00

18 honored · 11 strained · 1 broken · 3 not rated

pool-play

0.77of 1.00

19 honored · 5 strained · 4 broken · 5 not rated

mini-playoff

0.76of 1.00

18 honored · 8 strained · 3 broken · 4 not rated

status-quo

0.75of 1.00

16 honored · 4 strained · 4 broken · 9 not rated

two-cups

0.73of 1.00

17 honored · 10 strained · 3 broken · 3 not rated

two-cups-b

0.68of 1.00

15 honored · 11 strained · 4 broken · 3 not rated

What a season sells

This is where the dollars come from. We count the games of each kind in an average season of each format and put a price on each kind. A rotation game is the base price. A game with something riding on it, like a cup round, a pool game or a Gumbo game in the race, sells for more, and a championship game or a semifinal with a slot of its own sells for the most. Drag a slider and the table updates.

Every format gets a price tag: what a season of it would bring in, from media and to the local economy of the towns that host the games. You set what each kind of game is worth, in millions. A rematch earns less than a fresh game, and a game set up on a week's notice earns its town less. The number in brackets compares the format with today's schedule.

kind of game$M eachtwo-cupstwo-cups-bpools-playofffour-cupsmini-playoffchasepool-playseven-semisseven-settleseven-finaleight-finalstatus-quo
A season sells$1,591M$1,578M$1,572M$1,571M$1,567M$1,483M$1,393M$1,377M$1,373M$1,354M$1,322M$1,272M
against today's rotation×1.25×1.24×1.24×1.23×1.23×1.17×1.10×1.08×1.08×1.06×1.04×1.00
Conference final800.70.2111··1111·
Semifinal40··2.01.32··1.51.3···
Quarterfinal25··1.7·2.3·······
Sixteen-team cup final4022··········
Sixteen-team cup semifinal3044··········
Sixteen-team cup quarterfinal2588··········
Sixteen-team cup opener20············
Eight-team cup final34···4········
Eight-team cup semifinal20···8········
Eight-team cup opener20············
Pod final30····8·······
Pod opener15············
Pool game18··48··4842·····
Top pool game20······6·····
Gumbo game, the Chase's November20·····18······
Gumbo game, for a place2034.634.214.333.721.9··8.88.89.12.4·
Rotation game1522.723.64.92436.862460.760.961.968.672
Rivalry premium822.623.323.323.422.6242423.123.32422.924
Rematch penalty−33%1.91.32.62.73.2·6.01.81.81.51.6·
Short-notice penalty−20%31.631.69.328.417.314.3·7.87.77.7··

Counts are games a season, averaged over the run. The rivalry row counts games between protected rivals, which take the premium on top of their price; the penalty rows count rematches and games paired on a week's notice, which lose that share of their price or of their town's take, whatever else they are.

How the grades are made

  1. Every item on the card is measured by one number. Some come straight off the published schedule, like how many Saturdays a school knows in August or how many rivalries are locked in. The rest are averages over the simulated seasons, like how often one of the three strongest teams wins the title or how many rematches a season produces. Every number on the site says which run it came from.
  2. A rule turns the number into a grade. Each measure has a direction, higher is better, lower is better, or a target range, and two cutoffs: the value that earns a plus and the value that still earns a tilde. Anything past that is an ×. A few are measured against the current rotation's own number, because something like how much you know in August only makes sense compared with what the league has today. If a measure can't apply to a format, that item is left out of the math.
  3. A bold row's grade is the share of the items under it that the format gets right, a tilde counting as half.
  4. One item, Something Stinks, counts things that shouldn't happen, like a team being made to beat someone it already beat. It's graded the same way in reverse, a plus when the count is near zero, and its number is shown as a negative so it reads as the penalty it is.
  5. Footballness is the same share taken across every graded item, so a format that gets everything right scores 1.00 and one that gets nothing right scores 0.00.
patternmeasurehow it is calculatedthe rule
RRP Reserved Rivalry Pairprotected_playedProtected pairs played per season out of twenty-four, and the share of seasons in which all twenty-four are played. (of twenty-four)honors at 23.5 or more; strains at 22 or more; breaks below
TGA Thanksgiving Anchorthanksgiving_honoredOf the nine Thanksgiving-weekend fixtures, five in-conference and four with the ACC, the number played as scheduled on the last Saturday, averaged across seasons; beside it the number re-paired because of a final, and the share of seasons in which a title game was played as a Thanksgiving rivalry. (of nine last-Saturday fixtures)honors at 8.8 or more; strains at 7.5 or more; breaks below
RIO Rivalry in the Openerprotected_guaranteedProtected pairs guaranteed by fixed slots before the season, out of twenty-four. (guaranteed by fixed slots before the season)honors at 22 or more; strains at 18 or more; breaks below
NSC Neutral-Site Classicneutral_classics_keptOf the two neutral classics: one point each for the traditional Saturday at the traditional site, half a point for Red River on another fair Saturday, nothing for a Classic moved off its date. Two is the most a format can score. (both Classics on their date and ground)honors at 2 or more; strains at 1 or more; breaks below
EGC Every Game Countsconsequence_shareThe share of conference games whose result changes something: a participant's chance of winning the conference by more than a threshold, or who a participant plays next, or where. We estimate it by conditional replay, playing the game both ways with everything before it held and the same luck after it in both branches, so the difference between the branches is the game. Beside it we report the title part alone and the path part alone, so hope is visible separately from the title. (sampled conference games whose result moves a participant's title chance by five points or more, or changes who a participant plays next or where in that share of replays; each game replayed both ways from its Saturday with the same random numbers)honors at 0.6 or more; strains at 0.4 or more; breaks below; not rated when the run did not measure it
ERL Early Results Shape Late Opponentsadaptive_shareThe share of each school's nine conference games whose opponent was chosen by results rather than fixed before the season, averaged across schools. (between a third and two thirds adaptive)honors inside 0.3 to 0.7; strains inside 0.1 to 0.8; breaks outside
LPL Like Plays Likerecord_gap_lateThe mean absolute difference in conference win count between opponents in the last three adaptive Saturdays, compared with the same statistic under the published rotation. (late opponents closer in record than the rotation gives)honors at 0.85 times the Status Quo’s value or less; strains at 1 times the Status Quo’s value or less; breaks above; not rated for a format with no adaptive Saturdays
WPL Winners' Path, Losers' Pathsame_record_shareThe share of games in adaptive stages where both participants have identical win-loss records within that stage. (equal records meet in adaptive rounds)honors at 0.4 or more; strains at 0.15 or more; breaks below; not rated for a format with no adaptive Saturdays
FOP Fresh Opponent Preferredrepeat_pairingsRepeated pairings per season out of seventy-two conference games, split into structural repeats forced by bracket geometry, consolation repeats, and title-path repeats. Beside it we report the share of seasons in which the title game, where one exists, is a rematch. (seventy-two distinct pairings is the ideal)honors at 1 or less; strains at 5 or less; breaks above
CBC Cross-Bracket Consolationconsolation_repeatsRepeated pairings per season within consolation rounds only. (repeats among the beaten)honors at 0.5 or less; strains at 2 or less; breaks above; not rated for a format without cups
ORP Orthogonal Partitionsstructural_overlapThe number of school pairs that share a group in both stage partitions. Zero is achievable with four-team groups. (no pair shares a group twice)honors at 0 or less; strains at 4 or less; breaks above; not rated for a format with fewer than two grouped stages
PHS A Gumbo Game Has Stakesplacement_stakes_shareThe share of conference games, in weeks after the first stage, in which both participants have a defined placement consequence riding on the result. (late games with a defined place riding on them)honors at 0.8 or more; strains at 0.5 or more; breaks below
SCH Second Chancechampion_lost_shareThe share of seasons in which the eventual conference champion lost at least one conference game. If it is too low, no second chance exists; if it is too high, losses do not count. (a second chance exists and losses still count)honors inside 0.4 to 0.85; strains inside 0.2 to 0.95; breaks outside
TRO A Trophy to Lifttrophies_liftedTrophies lifted per season: one for each stage decided by a game its winner won, a cup final, a pod final, the conference final; one half for each stage decided by a table, a pool title or a championship read from the standings. A pool with no winner, three tied and nothing to separate them, lifts nothing. Three or more a season honors; one, the conference title alone decided on the field, strains; a championship by table alone breaks. (stages ending in hardware: one for a stage decided by a game its winner won, a half for one read from a table)honors at 3 or more; strains at 1 or more; breaks below
DEF Decisive Finaldecisive_final_shareThe share of seasons in which a game is played that was known at kickoff to decide the conference title outright. (a game known at kickoff to decide the title)honors at 0.9 or more; strains at 0.3 or more; breaks below
CFH Only Head-to-Head Carriestwo_way_h2h_shareThe share of two-team ties that are resolved by the head-to-head result, which should be all of them where the two have met, and beside it the share of Gumbo pairings steered away from a rematch by prior results. (two-way ties settled by the game they played)honors at 0.9 or more; strains at 0.5 or more; breaks below; not rated when the run did not measure it
NPC No Poll, No Committee, No Coin Flipresult_only_resolution_shareThe share of seasons in which the conference champion is determined by game results alone: record, head-to-head, and records against common opponents, without reaching a strength-of-schedule, scoring, or ratings rung. (the title settled without the draw)honors at 0.9 or more; strains at 0.6 or more; breaks below
CSF Super Final When Earnedsuper_final_shareThe share of seasons in which two or more different cup champions meet in a final, and beside it the number of last-Saturday games re-paired to make room for it. (among seasons with two or more champions, how often they meet)honors at 0.7 or more; strains at 0.25 or more; breaks below; not rated for a format without a final
WHM Whom, Not How Muchscoreboard_tiebreaksThe number of rungs in the published tiebreak, seeding, and selection ladders that consult points, margin, or any in-game statistic. The only acceptable number is zero. (zero is the only honorable number; one rung deep in the ladder strains, more breaks)honors at 0 or less; strains at 1 or less; breaks above
STK Something Stinkstitle_path_smellsTitle-path games that stink, per season, lower is better. The title path is the playoff, the champions' bracket, the super final and the title game, plus a cup or pod game between two schools still unbeaten in that stage. A game stinks when it is a rematch, when the two schools are two or more wins apart on the conference table at kickoff, or both; and an unbeaten school left uncrowned is a smell of its own. Half a smell a season or fewer honors; up to two strains; more breaks. Reported beside it: how often the first winner lost the rematch, and how often the worse record won the mismatch. (title-path games that stink, a season: a rematch a school already won, a gap of two or more wins on the table, an unbeaten school uncrowned; the anti-pattern, so the fewer the better)honors at 0.5 or less; strains at 2 or less; breaks above
SSU Strength Survives Upsetstop3_champion_shareThe share of seasons in which the conference champion is among the three strongest teams by latent strength, at each parity setting. (the strong usually win)honors at 0.85 or more; strains at 0.75 or more; breaks below
SMP Sufficient Sampletitle_sample_gamesThe number of the champion's conference games that bore on the title determination, averaged across seasons. (of the champion’s nine)honors at 8 or more; strains at 6 or more; breaks below
PSS Published Saturdayssaturdays_knownSaturdays per school whose venue status is known preseason, out of fourteen. (all fourteen Saturdays known in August)honors at 14 or more; strains at 12 or more; breaks below
KOP Known Opponentsopponents_knownConference opponents known preseason per school, out of nine. An opponent that changed after the season began, because a final re-paired the last Saturday, counts as not known. (the protected three and the first stage at least)honors at 6 or more; strains at 4 or more; breaks below
HAB Home/Away Balancehome_balanceThe share of schools finishing with four or five home-designated conference games, and the worst case observed. (four or five homes for everyone)honors at 0.95 or more; strains at 0.8 or more; breaks below
FVA Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponentvenue_flipsVenue flips per season: games where a school plays at a site other than its published designation. Zero is achievable. (games moved off the published designation)honors at 0.5 or less; strains at 3 or less; breaks above; not rated for a format with no adaptive Saturdays
HAP Home/Away PigeonholenoneNone. The limit is honored by a design that respects it and broken by one that ignores it.no rule yet; not rated
NTC Noticenotice_daysMedian days of notice between opponent determination and kickoff across adaptive games. (days between knowing the opponent and kickoff)honors at 14 or more; strains at 7 or more; breaks below; not rated for a format with no adaptive Saturdays
DFV Dynamic Field, Fair Venuevenue_by_rule_shareThe share of games whose participants were chosen by results and whose venue was assigned by a rule published before the season, rather than decided after the field was known. The only acceptable number is all of them. (chosen-field venues by a rule written first)honors at 1 or more; strains at 0.5 or more; breaks below; not rated when the run did not measure it
NIN Nine and Donecalendar_fitThe share of simulated seasons in which every school plays exactly nine conference games. Anything less than every season is a broken calendar. (nine, three, and two for everyone)honors at 0.99 or more; strains at 0.9 or more; breaks below
BYR Bye Rhythmmax_streakThe longest consecutive designated-road streak across schools, the number of schools with two byes in a row, and the number of Saturdays from W02 to W13 on which the league plays no conference game at all. (consecutive road Saturdays)honors at 2 or less; strains at 3 or less; breaks above
TTE Title Eventtitle_eventsWe value a season's championship games against the old title game, which counts as one. The conference final is one, a semifinal is half, a quarterfinal a quarter. A sixteen-team cup's final is half, its semifinals a fifth each and its quarterfinals a tenth. An eight-team cup's final is about a third and its semifinals a tenth. A pod final is a tenth. A format that adds up to at least what the old game was worth gets a plus; half of that gets a tilde; less is an ×. We also report the plain count of games and how many of them were fresh matchups. The value model on the scenarios page puts dollars on the same games. (championship inventory a season, valued against the old title game as one: the final one, a semifinal a half, a quarterfinal a quarter, a sixteen-team cup final a half, an eight-team cup final a third, a pod final a tenth, lesser rounds less; as much as the old game honors, half of it strains)honors at 1 or more; strains at 0.5 or more; breaks below
BID Protect the Bidsleague_bidsThe expected number of conference teams finishing with a playoff-grade record, under each playoff selection rule in canon, compared with the same number under the published rotation. We report it with the number of games the eventual top four played against each other. (playoff-grade records, against the rotation; a tenth fewer is a real cost)honors at 0.95 times the Status Quo’s value or more; strains at 0.75 times the Status Quo’s value or more; breaks below

The runs

scenariohash
seven-final9c565589d86baa1a
chasec39eab80da0be80b
seven-settle12b72926e99bce5f
eight-finalda29625e29b3323b
seven-semis8d0bdff18238fa9b
four-cupsce5613384bc875eb
pools-playoff22688848606033c3
pool-playd20d0959cf357ce6
mini-playoffc4079d2c283871ef
status-quo01140e6c91759773
two-cupsf11dec1c851ad6b0
two-cups-bc2ae640629390475

Where the numbers and our judgment disagree

Nowhere. The numbers and our judgment agree.

Reference runs

Ten thousand seasons of each format at three strength settings, so the rivalry numbers and the measures rest on more than a handful of Saturdays. Each run has a name you can look it up by.

scenariospreadtop-3 championrepeatsprotected playedThanksgiving kepthash
chase0.50.6820.00024.0009.000cc03c05f43016cc3
chase10.8490.00024.0009.0006f3dcb1e2cf90173
chase1.50.9140.00024.0009.000d9fb4e91cbdb7b30
four-cups0.50.6502.56923.2499.000bfe0970a719084af
four-cups10.8492.70923.3209.0006d9133f6539e4ae1
four-cups1.50.9222.76723.3739.000c202e16cd6a6499a
mini-playoff0.50.6423.78622.6128.1027f6cbd597fcafa64
mini-playoff10.8413.81222.7098.211083a516229ef0030
mini-playoff1.50.9153.84522.7688.266bc055ebdc7ed9641
pool-play0.50.6245.98424.0009.000768680799f228a85
pool-play10.8275.97224.0009.000e3d23657c7400b77
pool-play1.50.9115.99924.0009.0009daf45c994f7c87c
pools-playoff0.50.6523.44823.4698.2720411c071335a7618
pools-playoff10.8473.41423.5188.3324348065eef3e6e61
pools-playoff1.50.9213.42123.5428.355c2d4840c6a9c691f
seven-final0.50.6541.51524.0009.0006a02a856fd9bba61
seven-final10.8261.48824.0009.00045d3963b19b299e0
seven-final1.50.9021.46224.0009.0006d9e8d72940664c3
seven-settle0.50.6792.29223.3108.2489f59c904a7da743a
seven-settle10.8592.15723.3588.296f8b7e218cc4b3e97
seven-settle1.50.9242.18423.3028.2335c70d65c0a1d0068
status-quo0.50.6800.00024.0009.0003b23cf3cb0ac944e
status-quo10.8390.00024.0009.0000708f1811b535e13
status-quo1.50.9140.00024.0009.000a310801a008e9848
two-cups0.50.6641.73322.3848.0233e1c3940ed613dfa
two-cups10.8611.85322.5678.205bcb5e586499fea41
two-cups1.50.9361.93522.7118.346a29956427be5b3b5
two-cups-b0.50.6031.21023.0058.526fe8feac4ffd76e42
two-cups-b10.8051.29223.2338.7405ece9f01e594433a
two-cups-b1.50.8951.39323.3558.8522ab1e191804dfd73