STK · an anti-pattern: the measure counts what should not happen, and the fewer the better · measured by title path smells

Something Stinks

Context

Every fan knows the smell. Texas beat Oklahoma in Dallas in October and is told in December to do it again, or the first one did not count. A school that has not lost all year lines up against one with three losses, and if the three-loss school wins the one that mattered it is the champion and the unbeaten one is not. Nobody wrote a rule saying the field should be overturned; the format did it, and the people in the stands could smell it before anybody could say what was wrong.

This is an anti-pattern, the thing the other patterns leave behind when they are not quite enough. Fresh Opponent Preferred counts every rematch, including the ones among the beaten that hurt nobody. Only Head-to-Head Carries says a result should carry from one stage to the next, and the formats mostly obey it. What neither says is that a result on the field must not be put back in play, and that a school the table has already sorted below another should not be handed a second route to the title through that school.

Problem

There are two smells, and they come from the same place. A format that stages title games chooses who plays them, and the choice can ask a question the season already answered. The rematch is a school made to beat a school it already beat, with the first result thrown away if it loses. The back door opens when a school two or more wins behind on the table gets one game to take the title from the school ahead of it. Either way the earlier Saturdays are discounted, and the champion, whoever it is, carries a title that smells of the bracket rather than the season. The tournament literature has names for the properties the format has lost: a Condorcet-consistent rule always crowns a school that beat everyone it faced, and a monotonic rule never rewards a loss. A format with these smells is neither.

Forces

  • The smell pulls against the final. The two best schools have usually met. A final between them is a rematch by construction, and a final that avoids them is a final between the wrong schools.
  • The smell pulls against the bracket. A bracket fixed in August pairs whoever it pairs. The school that is 4-0 and the school that is 2-2 meet in the cup opener because the draw said so, and nobody can do anything about it.
  • The smell pulls against the second chance. Every losers' route back to the title is a back door for somebody.
  • The smell pulls against the sale. The games that stink are often the games a network wants: the rematch of the game of the year, the giant against the upstart.

Solution

Count the smells and show them. On the title path, a school made to beat a school it already beat, a school two or more wins ahead on the table made to risk its title against the one behind, and an unbeaten school that is not champion. Prefer formats that stage few such games, and where a format stages them by design, say so on the card.

Therefore

Never ask the field a question it already answered.

Measure

Title-path games that stink, per season, lower is better. The title path is the playoff, the champions' bracket, the super final and the title game, plus a cup or pod game between two schools still unbeaten in that stage. A game stinks when it is a rematch, when the two schools are two or more wins apart on the conference table at kickoff, or both; and an unbeaten school left uncrowned is a smell of its own. Half a smell a season or fewer honors; up to two strains; more breaks. Reported beside it: how often the first winner lost the rematch, and how often the worse record won the mismatch.

Lore

Nebraska did not win its own division in 2001, lost its last game to Colorado 62-36, and was sent to the Rose Bowl to play Miami for the national title anyway; it lost 37-14 and the formula that sent it was rewritten within the year. In 2008 Texas beat Oklahoma in Dallas, finished tied with it, and watched Oklahoma go to the Big 12 title game on a computer ranking. In 2011 LSU beat Alabama in Tuscaloosa in November and was made to play it again in New Orleans in January for the national title, and lost 21-0. The sport has a long memory for the Saturdays when the structure asked the field a question the field had already answered.

Supported by

Pulls against DEF Decisive FinalTTE Title EventSCH Second Chance

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors0
pool-play+ honors+ honors0
two-cups× breaks× breaks3.384
two-cups-b× breaks× breaks2.929
four-cups× breaks× breaks3.343
pools-playoff~ strains~ strains1.748
mini-playoff× breaks× breaks3.151
chase+ honors+ honors0
seven-settle~ strains~ strains0.825
seven-final+ honors+ honors0.455
seven-semis~ strains~ strains0.980
eight-final+ honors+ honors0.496
  • status-quo: honors. No title game, so nothing to stink; the table is the title.
  • pool-play: honors. The rank pools are the title path and they pair by place, so nobody meets twice and nobody meets across a gap.
  • two-cups: breaks. Two sixteen-team knockouts pair by the bracket, not the table, and a super final between champions who met in a cup is a rematch; the smells pile up.
  • two-cups-b: breaks. The super final is skipped when the champions already met, which removes one smell a few seasons and leaves the cup rounds as they were.
  • four-cups: breaks. Four cups and a champions' bracket: the openers pair unbeaten against beaten by the draw, and the bracket among champions is often a rematch.
  • pools-playoff: strains. The pools sort before the playoff, so the quarterfinals carry fewer mismatches, but a playoff of eight still rematches a pool opponent now and then.
  • mini-playoff: breaks. Knockout pods and then a knockout: a pod final is a title-path game, and the pods pair rivals first, record second.
  • chase: honors. The title is read from the table and the Swiss weeks pair like with like; there is no title-path game to stink.
  • seven-settle: strains. A final every year between the top of the table, a rematch some years, and a semifinal that lets the fourth seed at the first.
  • seven-final: honors. One final between the top two, a rematch in a minority of seasons and almost never a gap.
  • eight-final: honors. One final between the top two, a rematch in a third of seasons and a gap now and then, and it sits on the line.
  • seven-semis: strains. Semifinals every year: the fourth seed gets its shot at the first, and the final is a rematch in a third of seasons.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final