The scenarios
Twelve ways to run an SEC season: eight formats, and four variants of them. All of them fit nine conference games into fourteen Saturdays, keep the rivalries, and are done by Thanksgiving Saturday. Each one shows two numbers: its Footballness, which is how much of what makes an SEC season good it keeps, and what a season of it would bring in. The slider below decides which number orders the page.
Every format gets a price tag: what a season of it would bring in, from media and to the local economy of the towns that host the games. You set what each kind of game is worth, in millions. A rematch earns less than a fresh game, and a game set up on a week's notice earns its town less. The number in brackets compares the format with today's schedule.
scenario
Two Cups
The whole league plays a sixteen-team knockout in September and another in October, each on its own bracket. Nobody goes home: winners play winners and losers play losers, so every school finishes each one with a place from first to sixteenth. If two different schools win them, they meet in a Super Final in late November.
Rivalry ×22.6Gumbo ×34.6Cup QF ×8Cup SF ×4Cup F ×2F ×0.7
RIVL 0.50SEAS 1.00HOPE 0.83SORT 0.88FELD 0.70CRED 1.00KNOW 0.67FITS 0.50PAYS 0.75
scenario
Pools and Playoff
Two rounds of four-team pools, one in September and one in October, each a round robin. The pool winners go to a playoff of up to eight in November: quarterfinals, semifinals, and a final. The schools that miss it play Gumbo games against schools in the same boat.
Rivalry ×23.3Pool ×48Gumbo ×14.3F ×1SF ×2QF ×1.7
RIVL 0.75SEAS 0.75HOPE 0.83SORT 0.88FELD 0.90CRED 0.75KNOW 0.58FITS 1.00PAYS 0.75
scenario
Four Cups
There are four eight-team cups, two running side by side in September and two more on new groupings in October. Each cup is a three-week knockout: the winners play on for the cup, and the losers play Gumbo games for their place in it. The cup winners meet in a Champions' Bracket in November, semifinals and then a final, while everybody else plays Gumbo games.
Rivalry ×23.4Gumbo ×33.7Cup F ×4F ×1Cup SF ×8SF ×1.3
RIVL 0.75SEAS 1.00HOPE 1.00SORT 0.75FELD 0.80CRED 1.00KNOW 0.50FITS 1.00PAYS 0.75
scenario
Mini-Knockouts and Playoff
Twice, in September and again in October, every school plays in a four-team knockout pod: rivals open, then the winners play for the pod and the losers play for third. The pod winners go to a playoff of up to eight in November. Two rivalry weekends pick up the rivalries the pods miss.
Rivalry ×22.6Pod F ×8Gumbo ×21.9F ×1SF ×2QF ×2.3
RIVL 0.75SEAS 1.00HOPE 1.00SORT 0.88FELD 0.75CRED 0.75KNOW 0.42FITS 1.00PAYS 0.75
variant of Two Cups
Two Cups, no double jeopardy
The same two sixteen-team knockouts as Two Cups, with one difference: if the two winners already played each other along the way, that game stands and there is no Super Final. Only two winners who have not met play for the title.
Rivalry ×23.3Gumbo ×34.2Cup QF ×8Cup SF ×4Cup F ×2F ×0.2
RIVL 0.50SEAS 1.00HOPE 0.83SORT 0.88FELD 0.50CRED 0.75KNOW 0.67FITS 0.50PAYS 0.75
scenario
Championship Chase
Two rounds of four-team pools fill September and October. Then comes the Gumbo: for three Saturdays in November everybody goes in the pot and comes out paired with the school closest to them in the table, at home or away as scheduled in August. Whoever is on top after nine games is the champion. There is no title game.
Rivalry ×24Pool ×48Gumbo ×18
RIVL 1.00SEAS 0.75HOPE 1.00SORT 1.00FELD 0.70CRED 1.00KNOW 0.90FITS 1.00PAYS 0.25
scenario
Pool Play
Two rivalry weekends open September. In October every school plays in a pool with three others, once each. In November the schools are sorted into new pools by where they finished, so the four pool winners make up the top pool, and whoever wins the top pool is the champion. Thanksgiving is played as it always is.
Rivalry ×24Pool ×42Top pool ×6
RIVL 1.00SEAS 0.50HOPE 0.83SORT 0.67FELD 0.80CRED 0.50KNOW 1.00FITS 0.75PAYS 0.25
scenario
Seven and Settle
Seven conference games on the rotation, with the two Saturdays before Thanksgiving kept open. After seven, everyone within a game of the top is in: two schools and it is a final, three or four and it is semifinals and a final. Everybody else plays the school nearest them in the table, then their Thanksgiving rivalry.
Rivalry ×23.3F ×1Gumbo ×8.8SF ×1.3
RIVL 0.75SEAS 0.75HOPE 0.67SORT 0.83FELD 0.90CRED 1.00KNOW 0.75FITS 1.00PAYS 1.00
variant of Seven and Settle
Seven and a Final
The same seven-game rotation, but the top two by the table always play a final, and nobody else is in. Both finalists rest the Saturday before it and keep their Thanksgiving games, so nothing is ever displaced. The final is the week before Thanksgiving, unless the two finalists are Thanksgiving rivals, and then their Thanksgiving game is the final.
Rivalry ×24F ×1Gumbo ×9.1
RIVL 1.00SEAS 0.75HOPE 0.67SORT 0.83FELD 1.00CRED 0.75KNOW 0.83FITS 1.00PAYS 1.00
variant of Seven and Settle
Seven and Semis
The same seven-game rotation, with semifinals every year: everyone within a game of the top is in, three at the least and four at the most. Three and the top seed rests through to the final with its Thanksgiving game kept; four and it is two semifinals, then the final as the finalists’ ninth game, their Thanksgiving rivals paired with each other.
Rivalry ×23.1F ×1Gumbo ×8.8SF ×1.5
RIVL 0.75SEAS 0.75HOPE 0.67SORT 0.83FELD 0.90CRED 1.00KNOW 0.67FITS 1.00PAYS 0.75
variant of Seven and Settle
Eight and a Final
Eight conference games, all played by the second Saturday of November, then a final between the top two in the table. The final is the finalists’ ninth game: a finalist gives up its Thanksgiving rivalry, and the two rivals left behind play each other. The Saturday after the eighth game is the league’s nonconference Saturday, so nobody is idle for it.
Rivalry ×22.9F ×1Gumbo ×2.4
RIVL 0.75SEAS 0.50HOPE 0.50SORT 0.67FELD 1.00CRED 0.75KNOW 0.92FITS 1.00PAYS 1.00
scenario
Status Quo
This is what we already do, but without an SEC Championship Game. Each school plays three permanent opponents and six on a rotation, and when it is over all we have is the standings: too small a sample, and too few of the contenders ever met on the field.
Rivalry ×24
RIVL 1.00SEAS 0.25HOPE 0.50SORT 1.00FELD 0.60CRED 1.00KNOW 1.00FITS 1.00PAYS 0.50