ERL · measured by adaptive share
Early Results Shape Late Opponents
Supports SEAS The Season Is the PlayoffEGC Every Game CountsLPL Like Plays Like
Context
A schedule published in full before the season is a bet about who will be good, placed two years early by people who couldn't know. By November a 1-6 team is hosting a 7-0 team because that is what the rotation said, and the only people who wanted that game are the ones selling the parking.
Problem
When every opponent is fixed in advance, late-season games are informative only by accident. The funnel that could turn a nine-game sample into a ranking never gets to run, because the schedule was written before anybody knew what to sort.
Forces
- Information pulls against notice. The later an opponent is chosen, the more the game tells you and the less time anybody has to prepare or travel.
- Information pulls against tradition. Rivalry games are fixed, so the adaptive slots have to be carved out around them.
- Information pulls against venue. Adaptive opponents are easy and adaptive venues are hard, and the pigeonhole limit says how hard.
Solution
Reserve a defined share of each school's nine games as adaptive slots whose opponent is chosen by prior results, while fixing those slots' dates and venues before the season. Use the fixed slots for rivalries and the adaptive slots for sorting. Never let a rivalry depend on the sort, and never let a venue.
Therefore
Make between a third and two thirds of the conference schedule adaptive, and never the rivalry games or the venues.
Measure
The share of each school's nine conference games whose opponent was chosen by results rather than fixed before the season, averaged across schools.
Lore
The Swiss system has run chess tournaments since Zurich in 1895 on one rule: after each round, pair the players with the same score. It works because the schedule is written by the results. College football has never tried it, which is strange for a sport that claims its regular season is a playoff.
Supported by
LPL Like Plays LikeFVA Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent
Pulls against KOP Known OpponentsNTC Notice
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | × breaks | × breaks | 0 |
| pool-play | + honors | + honors | 0.333 |
| two-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.667 |
| two-cups-b | + honors | + honors | 0.667 |
| four-cups | + honors | + honors | 0.667 |
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.250 |
| mini-playoff | + honors | + honors | 0.472 |
| chase | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.250 |
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.139 |
| seven-final | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.139 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 0.139 |
| eight-final | × breaks | × breaks | 0.028 |
- status-quo: breaks. No opponent is chosen by results.
- pool-play: honors. The second pool's members are chosen by first-pool finish, and the Gumbo games follow.
- two-cups: honors. Most of the nine opponents depend on results; only the openers and the ninth game are known.
- four-cups: honors. Cup rounds after the opener and the final rounds adapt.
- pools-playoff: strains. Only the playoff and Gumbo games adapt.
- mini-playoff: honors. Second-round pod games and the playoff adapt.
- chase: strains. Two adaptive games of nine for most schools, three for the ACC four; just under the third the pattern asks for.
- eight-final: breaks. Only the final and the games the final displaces adapt; eight of nine are set in August.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final