SCH · measured by champion lost share

Second Chance

Context

A single-elimination season is thrilling and brutal. Georgia lost to Alabama in Atlanta in December 2021 and beat Alabama for the national title a month later. The loss was real and so was the second chance, and nobody who watched the second game thought the first one should have ended things. The rank-banded pool offers the same thing a different way: lose in your pool and you drop a band, but a new round robin begins and you can win that one. Two cups make it structural, because a second championship starts in October for everybody.

Problem

Without a second chance, a September upset ends a season and the rest of the autumn is a formality. With too many, losses stop mattering and the sample shrinks until the title is a tournament.

Forces

  • Mercy pulls against consequence. Each extra path lowers the cost of a loss.
  • Mercy pulls against clarity. Two cup champions need a rule to make one conference champion.
  • Mercy pulls against the calendar. A second structure spends Saturdays that could be rivalry or Gumbo games.

Solution

Run two independent structures over the season, partitioned differently, so a school knocked out of one is a fresh contender in the other. Resolve two different winners with a final when they have not met, and by the game they played when they have, and never run a third.

Therefore

Give every school two structurally equal shots at the title, and never three.

Measure

The share of seasons in which the eventual conference champion lost at least one conference game. If it is too low, no second chance exists; if it is too high, losses do not count.

Supported by

Pulls against EGC Every Game CountsSMP Sufficient Sample

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors0.556
pool-play+ honors+ honors0.581
two-cups+ honors+ honors0.699
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors0.699
four-cups+ honors+ honors0.651
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors0.550
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors0.607
chase+ honors+ honors0.560
seven-settle+ honors+ honors0.540
seven-final+ honors+ honors0.516
seven-semis+ honors+ honors0.541
eight-final+ honors+ honors0.490
  • status-quo: honors. The champion has a loss in about six seasons of ten. There is no fresh structure, but the measure asks whether losses are survivable, and they are.
  • pool-play: honors. The pool winner who stumbles in the top pool still wins it more often than not; the champion has a loss in six seasons of ten.
  • two-cups: honors. Two full championships.
  • four-cups: honors. Two stages of four cups.
  • pools-playoff: honors. A pool winner can lose a pool game and still win it all; the champion has a loss in six seasons of ten.
  • mini-playoff: honors. Two independent pod stages.
  • chase: honors. The champion has lost along the way in about six seasons of ten; a second chance exists and losses still count.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final