HOPE

Something to Play For

Context

Most of sixteen schools will not win the conference this year, and most of them know it by the first of October. In the old divisional league a 4-4 team in November was playing for a bowl in Shreveport and not much else. Yet those schools have a hundred thousand people in the stands, and the folks in the stands did not stop caring when the title hopes did. The question is whether the format gives them something real to care about.

Problem

A format that points every bit of its structure at the trophy leaves a dozen schools playing unstructured games with no defined objective in November. The games still get played, but they do not mean anything, and everybody in the building can feel it.

Forces

  • Hope pulls against consequence. If a September loss can be survived, it counted for less, and every second chance lowers the price of a loss.
  • Hope pulls against money. A fifth-place game sells less than a title game, so whatever the eliminated play for has to be cheap in Saturdays.
  • Hope pulls against clarity. Two shots at the title means two winners some years, and a rule to make one champion.
  • Mercy pulls against dignity. A Gumbo game nobody wants to be in is worse than no game at all.

Solution

Give every school a defined finishing objective in every round, with a consequence attached: a cup place, a pool rank, a standings tier that feeds bowl order or next year's seed. And give every school a second structural shot at the title, by running two stages partitioned differently, so a school knocked out of one is a fresh contender in the other.

Therefore

Make placement carry stakes, and give everyone a second chance, but never a third.

Patterns

  • PHS, Placement Has Stakes. The share of late games where both sides have a defined place riding on it.
  • SCH, Second Chance. How often the champion has lost a game along the way.
  • TRO, A Trophy to Lift. How many of a season's stages end with a trophy, whether lifted after the game that decided it or read off a table.

Measure

Taken together: how many late-season games have something defined riding on them for both schools, and how often the champion is a school that lost along the way. A format honors this principle when the first is high and the second is in the middle, neither never nor always.

Lore

The NCAA basketball tournament played a third-place game until 1981 and the World Cup still does, and the people who complain about it are never the people playing in it. Alabama lost to Auburn and missed the conference title game in 2017, and then won the national championship anyway. The second chance was real and the season was better for it.

Supported by

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo~ strains
pool-play+ honors
two-cups+ honors
two-cups-b+ honors
four-cups+ honors
pools-playoff~ strains
mini-playoff~ strains
chase+ honors
seven-settle~ strains
seven-final~ strains
seven-semis~ strains
eight-final~ strains
  • status-quo: strains. A standings position carries only whatever meaning a committee gives it.
  • pool-play: honors. Every pool has a rank and every rank has a next pool.
  • two-cups: honors. Classification settles all sixteen places in each cup, and there are two cups.
  • four-cups: honors. Each cup settles eight places, and there are two stages.
  • pools-playoff: strains. Gumbo games are played but not organized into finishing positions.
  • mini-playoff: strains. The same holds.
  • chase: honors. The standings are the whole format, and every game moves a place.