FOP · measured by repeat pairings

Fresh Opponent Preferred

Context

November 5, 2011. LSU beat Alabama 9-6 in overtime in Tuscaloosa in a game that had been called the game of the century for a month beforehand. Two months later the BCS staged the rematch in New Orleans for the national title, Alabama won 21-0, and a large part of the sport has distrusted rematches ever since. Georgia beat Texas twice in 2024, once in Austin and once in Atlanta, and the second one settled nothing the first one had not.

Problem

Any structure that sorts by strength tends to bring the same two good teams together twice. A repeated pairing reveals nothing new, denies a fresh matchup to everybody watching, and invites the argument that the first result should have counted. In a nine-game season, a repeat is a ninth of the evidence thrown away.

Forces

  • Freshness pulls against sorting. The more you match by record, the more you rematch at the top.
  • Freshness pulls against the final. The two best teams may have already met, so a fresh final means somebody else plays in it and a final between the two best means a rematch. When those collide, the final wins and the rematch is the price.
  • Freshness pulls against structure. Rigid brackets with fixed venues force repeats, and flexible pairing avoids them but needs a solver.
  • Freshness pulls against rivalry. Rivals must meet once, and the structure has to keep them from meeting twice.

Solution

Treat a repeat pairing as a cost everywhere an opponent is chosen. Partition the stages so no pair can share a group twice. Pool the eliminated across brackets so the pairing has choices. Use earlier results to steer Gumbo games away from rematches. Accept a rematch only where a real final demands it.

Therefore

Design so that seventy-two conference games are seventy-two different pairings, and measure how close each format gets.

Measure

Repeated pairings per season out of seventy-two conference games, split into structural repeats forced by bracket geometry, consolation repeats, and title-path repeats. Beside it we report the share of seasons in which the title game, where one exists, is a rematch.

Supported by

Pulls against LPL Like Plays LikeDEF Decisive FinalCSF Super Final When Earned

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors+ honors0
pool-play× breaks× breaks5.993
two-cups~ strains~ strains1.862
two-cups-b~ strains~ strains1.321
four-cups~ strains~ strains2.699
pools-playoff~ strains~ strains2.646
mini-playoff~ strains~ strains3.165
chase+ honors+ honors0
seven-settle~ strains~ strains1.847
seven-final~ strains~ strains1.484
seven-semis~ strains~ strains1.836
eight-final~ strains~ strains1.577
  • status-quo: honors. There are none, because no opponent is chosen by results.
  • pool-play: breaks. The rank pools re-pair September's rivalry-weekend opponents and can seat a Thanksgiving pair in one band: about six repeats a season.
  • two-cups: strains. With the rematch rule and consolation that knows which pairs are fixed to meet later, under two repeats a season; what remains is the brackets' last rounds and Red River fixed on W07.
  • four-cups: strains. Two stages of eight-team cups, the rematch rule, and consolation that avoids pairs fixed to meet later: about two repeats a season.
  • pools-playoff: strains. None before the playoff, a few inside it and in placement: about three a season.
  • mini-playoff: strains. A few a season, some of them in the pod rounds.
  • chase: honors. None under a well-chosen venue template.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final