NTC · measured by notice days

Notice

Context

Even with the venue fixed, an opponent decided on Saturday night for next Saturday gives television six days to promote it, the visiting fans six days to book, and the coaches six days to prepare. The pros do it every January and it works. But a conference that could give more notice and does not is choosing drama over its own fans.

Problem

Adaptive formats compress notice to one week by default. Some of those decisions could be made earlier, and the format should look for them.

Forces

  • Notice pulls against information. Pairing two weeks ahead uses results that are a week staler.
  • Notice pulls against the top. The top of the table changes most from week to week, while the middle is stable enough to pair early.
  • Notice pulls against venue. With the Saturdays published, the visiting side knows the city and just not the opponent, which halves the problem.

Solution

Where a stage is rank-banded, the band is known when the first stage ends, which gives weeks of notice of the opponent set. Where pairing is round by round, publish next week's pairing the moment the last game ends, and consider two-week pairing for the middle of the table where it costs little.

Therefore

Maximize the days between an opponent's announcement and kickoff, and publish venues years ahead so notice is only ever about the opponent.

Measure

Median days of notice between opponent determination and kickoff across adaptive games.

Lore

The NFL announces its wild-card matchups on Sunday night and plays them Saturday, and the fans of twelve teams find a way. The difference is that those fans know their own stadium is either hosting or it is not. A week's notice of the opponent is survivable, but a week's notice of the venue empties the hotels.

Supported by

Pulls against LPL Like Plays LikeERL Early Results Shape Late Opponents

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo+ honors· n/a
pool-play+ honors+ honors14
two-cups~ strains~ strains7
two-cups-b~ strains~ strains7
four-cups~ strains~ strains7
pools-playoff~ strains~ strains7
mini-playoff~ strains~ strains7
chase~ strains~ strains7
seven-settle~ strains~ strains7
seven-final~ strains~ strains7
seven-semis~ strains~ strains7
eight-final+ honors+ honors15.665
  • status-quo: honors. The opponents are known years ahead.
  • pool-play: honors. The rank pools are drawn the Saturday the first stage ends, so all three of their opponents are known two to four weeks ahead.
  • two-cups, four-cups, pools-playoff, mini-playoff, chase: strains. Adaptive games get one week.
  • eight-final: honors. The final is known two weeks out, with the nonconference Saturday between, or three when it moves to Thanksgiving Saturday; the re-paired games are known the week before.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final