WHM · measured by scoreboard tiebreaks

Whom, Not How Much

Context

Points are always available: every game produces a score, a score is a number, and a number can break a tie, which is exactly why it should not be allowed to. The moment margin counts for anything beyond the game it was scored in, a coach up four touchdowns in the fourth quarter has a reason to keep throwing, and a coach down four has a reason to quit. The game being played gets bent by a game that has not been played yet.

Problem

Tiebreak ladders that reach for points scored, margin of victory, or yards reward running up the score, punish sportsmanship, and turn the last quarter of a decided game into a strategic exercise nobody in the stands came to see. They also reward the beaten team for lying down, and both of those are poison.

Forces

  • Completeness pulls against purity. Points will resolve any tie, which is their appeal and their danger.
  • The scoreboard pulls against the clock. Any rule that counts margin changes how a coach uses the fourth quarter of a game that is already won.
  • The scoreboard pulls against mercy. The team that pulls its starters at 42-7 is behaving well and getting punished for it.

Solution

Never consult points scored, margin, yardage, or any in-game statistic in a tiebreak, a seeding, or a selection. Resolve what results can resolve. Where results cannot, prefer a rule that sends nobody or everybody, or a published draw, over a rung that reads the scoreboard.

Therefore

Break ties by whom you beat, never by how much.

Measure

The number of rungs in the published tiebreak, seeding, and selection ladders that consult points, margin, or any in-game statistic. The only acceptable number is zero.

Lore

In 1982 West Germany and Austria played out a 1-0 in Gijón because both knew that score sent them both through and sent Algeria home, and the crowd waved money at the pitch. In 1994 Barbados scored on its own goal on purpose because a tournament rule made a golden goal count double. In 2002 the BCS told its computers to stop counting margin of victory because coaches were leaving starters in to pad the number. Every one of those is the scoreboard reaching out of its own game to wreck another.

Supported by

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo~ strains~ strains1
pool-play+ honors+ honors0
two-cups+ honors+ honors0
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors0
four-cups+ honors+ honors0
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors0
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors0
chase+ honors+ honors0
seven-settle+ honors+ honors0
seven-final+ honors+ honors0
seven-semis+ honors+ honors0
eight-final+ honors+ honors0
  • status-quo: strains. The conference's own published ladder reaches a capped scoring-margin rung before the coin.
  • pool-play: honors. Two-team ties by head-to-head; three-way pool ties send nobody or everybody.
  • two-cups: honors. Knockouts settle the cups, and the seeding rules never read the scoreboard.
  • four-cups: honors. The same, knockouts with seeding by results alone.
  • pools-playoff: honors. The selection ladder is results only by rule.
  • mini-playoff: honors. The same, a selection ladder that is results only.
  • chase: honors. The standings ladder is results only by rule.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final