FITS
Fits Inside the Season
Supports FOOT Footballness
Context
The season runs fourteen Saturdays, from the last weekend of August to the Saturday after Thanksgiving, with nine conference games, three out of conference, and two off, and it is done before the national playoff begins. Four schools have an ACC rival on the last Saturday and need their ninth conference game earlier. Two neutral-site classics sit on fixed October dates. That is the whole calendar, and nobody is getting a bigger one, because the players are students and the academic calendar comes first.
Problem
Every format in this language wants more Saturdays than exist. A title final, a rivalry round, two classics, and two three-round stages do not all fit without somebody getting a special case. Special cases are what kill formats, because each one is a rule nobody can remember and a fan who feels cheated.
Forces
- Rounds pull against Saturdays. Two stages of three rounds, a two-round final, and a rivalry round add up to nine conference Saturdays, with five left for nonconference games and byes and no slack for the October classics.
- Symmetry pulls against the four. The ACC-rivalry schools need a different November, so any solution gives them a different shape, and the only question is whether that shape is written down as a rule.
- Slack pulls against guarantees. A season with no slack cannot absorb a hurricane.
- Rhythm pulls against counts. Many templates satisfy the arithmetic, and fewer of them avoid three straight road games or a bye on the last Saturday.
Solution
Build the calendar as a validated template: every school, every Saturday, with the counts proven under every result path. Prefer designs whose template needs no result-dependent exception. Where an exception cannot be avoided, write it down as a rule with a name. Then build rhythm into the template search rather than checking it afterward: no long road streaks, byes spaced apart, and no bye on the last Saturday for anyone who does not need one.
Therefore
Play nine conference games in fourteen Saturdays, finish before December, and allow no exception you cannot name.
Patterns
- NIN, Nine and Done. Whether the template fits on every path and how many named exceptions it needs.
- BYR, Bye Rhythm. Whether the template has an ugly stretch for anybody.
Measure
Taken together: whether every school plays nine conference games inside fourteen Saturdays under every path without an unnamed exception, and how rough the worst school's rhythm is. A format honors this principle when the answer to the first is yes and the second is nothing a coach would complain about in public.
Lore
The twelve-team Big 12 played a round robin plus a title game and found out that a round robin leaves no room for anything else, including the national title game it kept losing on the first Saturday of December.
Supported by
NIN Nine and DoneBYR Bye Rhythm
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | + honors | ||
| pool-play | + honors | ||
| two-cups | + honors | ||
| two-cups-b | + honors | ||
| four-cups | ~ strains | ||
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ||
| chase | + honors | ||
| seven-settle | ~ strains | ||
| seven-final | + honors | ||
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ||
| eight-final | + honors |
- status-quo: honors.
- pool-play: honors. Three games, three games, and three games, all on fixed dates.
- two-cups: honors. Two four-round cups and a ninth game fit the fourteen.
- four-cups: strains. The final rounds crowd the October classic.
- pools-playoff: strains. The playoff calendar works for some finalist sets and not others.
- mini-playoff: strains. The same holds.
- chase: honors. The template fits, and the four ACC schools play all three adaptive weeks.
- eight-final: honors. Everyone plays nine, with two byes and the nonconference Saturday in November.