DFV · measured by venue by rule share

Dynamic Field, Fair Venue

Context

Sometimes the field has to be chosen by results: eight schools from sixteen by record, or two cup champions, or four. The pigeonhole rule says their published venues won't line up, so somebody hosts who wasn't promised a home game, or somebody travels who was promised one. The question is whether the rule for that was written before the season or made up on a conference call the Sunday after.

Problem

A venue decided after the field is known looks like favoritism however it was decided, because the people deciding it know who benefits, while a venue rule written before the field is known can't favor anybody, because nobody knew who would be in it.

Forces

  • A drawn lot pulls against merit. Lots are fair and blind, and they can send the top seed on the road.
  • Gumbo choice pulls against variety. Letting the higher-placed team choose rewards the season, and left alone it puts the same strong school at home against the same rival every year.
  • Both pull against the rivals in the openers. A school whose fixed openers are its rivals has fewer slots left to vary, so the restrictions must be written with those schools in mind.
  • A neutral site pulls against everybody. It solves the fairness problem by giving nobody a home, which is the one outcome every school's fans like least.

Solution

For every game whose field is chosen by results, publish before the season how its venue will be decided. You can draw lots in advance so each possible pairing already has a host, let the higher-placed school choose under restrictions that make the venue flip year to year between the same two schools, or name a neutral site. Whichever it is, the rule exists before the first kickoff, and the schools that might be in the game have read it.

Therefore

When the field is chosen by results, decide the venue by a rule written before the season, by lot or by placement, and never week by week.

Measure

The share of games whose participants were chosen by results and whose venue was assigned by a rule published before the season, rather than decided after the field was known. The only acceptable number is all of them.

Lore

The NFL settles its draft order ties with a coin flip in front of cameras, and the 1968 flip that gave O.J. Simpson to Buffalo is still argued about, but nobody says it was rigged. A rule that was visible in advance survives a bad outcome, and one that has to be explained afterward doesn't.

Supported by

Pulls against FVA Fixed Venue, Adaptive Opponent

Seen in

scenariolanguagesimulatedvalue
status-quo· n/a· n/a
pool-play· n/a· n/a
two-cups+ honors+ honors1
two-cups-b+ honors+ honors1
four-cups+ honors+ honors1
pools-playoff+ honors+ honors1
mini-playoff+ honors+ honors1
chase· n/a· n/a
seven-settle+ honors+ honors1
seven-final+ honors+ honors1
seven-semis+ honors+ honors1
eight-final+ honors+ honors1
  • two-cups: honors. The super final's venue is decided by a published rule.
  • four-cups: honors. The final among champions has its venue rule written first.
  • pools-playoff: honors. The eight qualifiers' venues are set by lot or Gumbo choice, published before the season.
  • mini-playoff: honors. The same as Pools Playoff.
  • Others: not applicable; no chosen field.

See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final