SEAS
The Season Is the Playoff
Supports FOOT Footballness
Context
For a hundred years college football sold one thing no other sport could: a regular season you could not afford to lose. One loss in October could end a national championship run, and two could end a conference one. Folks planned their autumns around it, and the game got its gravity from it. The SEC's own slogan, "It just means more," says the same thing.
The national playoff keeps growing, from twelve teams now to sixteen or two dozen soon enough, and a bigger bracket forgives a loss, then two, then three. Once that happens, the only place the old claim can still be true is inside a conference's own format. The conference decides whether its season is a playoff or a seeding exercise.
Problem
In a fixed schedule, meaning pools wherever the contenders happen to be and drains out of everywhere else. By the second week of November a 2-6 team is hosting a 7-1 team because a rotation written two years ago said so, and neither one of them has anything riding on it. The season is still long, but it has stopped being a playoff and turned into a résumé.
Forces
- Consequence pulls against sample. The more one game decides, the fewer games the title rests on, and a season that is all knockout comes down to a handful of coin flips.
- Consequence pulls against mercy. If every Saturday is life or death, the schools that lose early have nothing to play for by October.
- Consequence pulls against foresight. A game can only decide something later in the season if that something is not fixed yet, whether an opponent, a round, or a place that depends on the result.
- Consequence pulls against tradition. The games people care most about are fixed years ahead, so the adaptive slots have to be carved out around them.
Solution
Build the season so that what happens this Saturday changes what happens next Saturday, for every school, in every week. Knockout rounds do this by nature, rank-banded pools and Swiss weeks do it by letting the standings pick the opponent, and Gumbo brackets do it for the schools out of the title race. Let early results shape late opponents, and leave no stretch of the season where a school's remaining opponents and its possible finishes are both already settled.
Therefore
Make every game count, by letting early results shape late opponents.
Patterns
- EGC, Every Game Counts. The share of Saturdays that move somebody's title or placement chances.
- ERL, Early Results Shape Late Opponents. The share of a school's schedule chosen by what it has done rather than by a rotation.
Measure
Taken together: how many of the seventy-two conference games change somebody's chances, and how many of each school's nine opponents were chosen by results. A format honors this principle when both are high and the first stays high in November.
Lore
In 2007 two-loss LSU won the national title, and in the years since the sport has conceded that one loss is survivable, then two. A conference season can still refuse that concession. Ohio State and Michigan in 2006, first against second on the last Saturday with everything on the line, is the kind of game this principle tries to produce on purpose instead of waiting for.
Supported by
HOPE Something to Play ForSORT Like Plays LikeEGC Every Game CountsERL Early Results Shape Late Opponents
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | ~ strains | ||
| pool-play | + honors | ||
| two-cups | + honors | ||
| two-cups-b | + honors | ||
| four-cups | + honors | ||
| pools-playoff | + honors | ||
| mini-playoff | + honors | ||
| chase | + honors | ||
| seven-settle | + honors | ||
| seven-final | + honors | ||
| seven-semis | + honors | ||
| eight-final | ~ strains |
- status-quo: strains. The standings decide the champion, so games between schools out of the race decide nothing.
- pool-play: honors. The first three games pick your pool for the next three, and the next three pick your place.
- two-cups: honors. Every cup game is a knockout for that cup.
- four-cups: honors. The same holds at eight-team scale, twice over.
- pools-playoff: honors. Six games pick the eight, and the eight play knockouts.
- mini-playoff: honors. Four knockout pod games and two rivalry rounds lead into a knockout.
- chase: honors. The standings pick the opponent every week of November.
- eight-final: strains. The published eighth game decides only who is in the final, and the standings do the sorting rather than the schedule.