BID · measured by league bids
Protect the Bids
Supports PAYS The Format Pays Its Way
Context
At the end of November a committee in a hotel ballroom looks at records, and a 9-3 team from a league that sorted itself hard looks the same on paper as a 9-3 team from a league that didn't. Every game between two contenders hands one of them a loss that a softer schedule would never have charged. A conference that sorts itself too well can cost its own teams their playoff bids.
Problem
A 4-0 team that spends the back half of the season playing other 4-0 teams can finish 5-3 and look, from outside, like a team that fell apart. Spread that across the top of the table and a format built to find the best team can send fewer teams to the playoff than a format that sorts nothing. Unless the conference's bids are guaranteed, the harder it sorts its contenders, the fewer of them the committee sees with a playoff-grade record.
Forces
- Sorting pulls against bids. Letting the best play the best costs losses, and that cost has to be shown next to the benefit.
- Bids pull against the season. If you keep contenders apart to protect their résumés, the season stops working as a playoff.
- The playoff's rules change the trade. A conference guaranteed its seats pays nothing nationally for sorting, but when the seats are at large, every game between contenders is a bet on how the committee will read the loss.
- Depth pulls against the top. A format that beats up the top four may still send more teams than one that leaves the top four unbeaten and the next eight unsorted.
Solution
Under each playoff rule the conference might face, count how many conference teams come out of November with a playoff-grade record. Report it next to the sorting measures so you can see the trade. Prefer formats that concentrate the sorting in enough games to be decisive and no more, and that stop short of forcing a fourth or fifth contender game on the same school.
Therefore
Don't send the league's best teams into December with losses the playoff committee won't forgive, and say plainly how many bids a format costs.
Measure
The expected number of conference teams finishing with a playoff-grade record, under each playoff selection rule in canon, compared with the same number under the published rotation. We report it with the number of games the eventual top four played against each other.
Lore
In 2024 the SEC sent three teams to the playoff and a 9-3 Alabama stayed home while an 11-2 SMU went, and all three of Alabama's losses were to conference opponents. The 2008 Big 12 South had three one-loss teams, and the committee of the day sent one of them to the title game and left the other two to argue. A conference that plays a harder schedule than its neighbors and isn't paid for it is doing its neighbors a favor.
Supported by
SCH Second ChanceKOP Known Opponents
Pulls against LPL Like Plays LikeEGC Every Game CountsWPL Winners' Path, Losers' Path
Seen in
| scenario | language | simulated | value |
|---|---|---|---|
| status-quo | + honors | + honors | 3.620 |
| pool-play | ~ strains | ~ strains | 3.126 |
| two-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.718 |
| two-cups-b | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.736 |
| four-cups | ~ strains | ~ strains | 2.946 |
| pools-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 3.259 |
| mini-playoff | ~ strains | ~ strains | 3.032 |
| chase | ~ strains | ~ strains | 3.339 |
| seven-settle | + honors | + honors | 3.445 |
| seven-final | + honors | + honors | 3.455 |
| seven-semis | ~ strains | ~ strains | 3.409 |
| eight-final | + honors | + honors | 3.639 |
- status-quo: honors. The rotation is the only thing that brings contenders together.
- pool-play: strains. The top pool is four contenders playing each other.
- two-cups: strains. Two full knockouts hand out losses to everybody, and a season averages 2.7 playoff-grade records against the rotation's 3.6, right on the line between strains and breaks.
- two-cups-b: strains. With no super final in most years, a few more records come through clean than in Two Cups, enough to sit on the line rather than under it.
- four-cups: strains. The top schools play three straight contenders in each cup, and then a final.
- pools-playoff: strains. Each of the eight who qualify can take up to three more losses.
- mini-playoff: strains. The same holds for the pod knockouts and the playoff.
- chase: strains. The top of the table plays three Swiss weeks against each other.
- eight-final: honors. Only the loser of the final takes a bracket loss, and the eighth game is a rotation game like any other.
- seven-settle: honors. Seven rotation games and then two weekends among the top of the table cost about a sixth of a playoff-grade record a season (3.4 against the rotation's 3.6), just inside the line.
- seven-final: honors. One final instead of two weekends costs about the same (3.5 against 3.6).
- seven-semis: strains. Two weekends with three or four in the field hand out one more bracket loss than a final does (3.4 against 3.6), a hair outside the line.
See it: status-quopool-playtwo-cupstwo-cups-bfour-cupspools-playoffmini-playoffchaseseven-settleseven-finalseven-semiseight-final